Blogs Will Vybz Kartel Be Freed Or Face Retrial? Here’s What The Bahamas Court Of Appeal Did In A Very Similar Case

  • March 26, 2024


  • 0 favorites

‘King of Dancehall’ Vybz Kartel‘s future hangs in the balance as Jamaica’s Court of Appeal weighs whether to free him or order a retrial following the UK-based Privy Council’s overturning of his murder conviction. The ruling parallels the case of Simeon Bain, the so-called “Burger King Killer” in the Bahamas, who spent 13 years in prison before he was released instead of retried.

Kartel (Adidja Palmer) and three co-accused — Shawn ‘Storm’ Campbell, Kahira Jones, and Andre ‘Mad Suss’ St John — have served over 12 years after they were found guilty in 2014 of murdering Clive ‘Lizard’ Williams in 2011. The Fever artist initially received the harshest sentence, with over 30 years until eligible for parole. The conviction was upheld by Jamaica’s Court of Appeal in 2020, but the Privy Council, the island’s highest court, overturned it earlier this month, citing serious jury management issues, particularly the continuation of the trial with a ‘tainted’ juror, which had compromised the fairness of the trial.

Bahamian Simeon Bain was convicted of kidnapping and murdering Burger King assistant manager Rashad ‘Shanty’ Morris after a failed attempt to rob the restaurant’s safe in 2009. The prosecution sought the death penalty, but Bain was sentenced to life in prison in 2013. In 2017, the Bahamas Court Of Appeal upheld his convictions but allowed the appeal against the life sentence, substituting a sentence of 55 years.

In April 2020, the Privy Council overturned Bain’s convictions, ruling that he did not have a fair trial because he was forced to represent himself after his lawyer resigned. Describing Bain’s case as one “of serious mismanagement,” the Privy Council noted that “if matters had been handled properly,” Bain would either have been persuaded to retain his original attorney or would have obtained an alternative choice, giving him a fair trial. Like in Kartel’s case, the Privy Council also sent Bain’s case back to the local Court of Appeal to consider whether he would face a new trial, according to The Tribune.

It took the Bahamas Court of Appeal almost two years to decide that Bain should be freed—a decision that Kartel’s attorney, Isat Buchanan, hopes will happen much sooner in his case, and one that Jamaica’s prosecutors are keen to avoid.

In explaining its ruling, the Bahamas court cited the passage of 13 years since the crime, the impracticality of a retrial amidst a heavy backlog of cases, and the anticipated “ordeal” a new trial would entail for Bain, Morris’ family, and the public.

“This is not an easy call,” the court wrote in its February 2022 ruling, the Nassau Guardian reported.

“However, having considered the various factors, we are satisfied that notwithstanding the seriousness of the offenses and their prevalence, these offences took place nearly 13 years ago and the case is effectively an old case. … We are satisfied that in this particular case, it is not in the interests of justice for the appellant to undergo a fresh trial.”

The appellate court also noted that both sides would incur a financial cost if a new trial were held, though it said it is in the interest of justice that “persons who commit violent crimes are brought to justice, and society is well served by putting violent criminals in prison.”



There are no comments yet. Add a comment.

Video CMS powered by ViMP (Ultimate) © 2010-2024